Home > Recent Post > S-Comm Immigration Initiative Is Bad for Our Health – Karen Hacker, Jennifer Kasper, and Juliana Morris

S-Comm Immigration Initiative Is Bad for Our Health – Karen Hacker, Jennifer Kasper, and Juliana Morris

Karen Hacker,1,2 Jennifer Kasper,1,3 and Juliana Morris1
1Harvard Medical School, 2Institute for Community Health, 3Massachusetts General Hospital

After much deliberation, Massachusetts Governor Deval Patrick decided this month not to sign the Secure Communities (S-Comm) program, following the lead of New York, Illinois, and other states. While this is a significant step in protecting immigrants’ rights, health care providers need to be vigilant. It is important to understand the potential negative health implications of this program, which could affect all communities in Massachusetts and across the United States.

Under S-Comm, a program of the U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE), fingerprints of arrestees in local police precincts are automatically cross-checked against a central ICE database. If there is a “hit,” indicating that the individual is in the US without authorization, ICE is automatically notified and may detain him or her and/or initiate deportation proceedings. This can occur even if the individual is only arrested and never convicted of any criminal act. States are refusing to sign on because they say it does not meet its stated goal of deporting hardened criminals. ICE’s own statistics reveal that more than half of people detained by the program are non-criminals. There is also concern that signing onto S-Comm will negatively affect the relationship between immigrant communities and local law enforcement since immigrants will be less likely to work with local and state police to fight crime.

The S-Comm implementation carries serious health and public health implications for some of the most vulnerable communities.  In particular, we are concerned about three negative health-related outcomes: the effects of stress and anxiety on the physical and mental health of immigrants; immigrants’ increased vulnerability to crime; and decreased health care utilization by immigrants.

A recent study conducted by the Institute for Community Health in Everett, a small city north of Boston, found that ICE presence in the community led to increased levels of fear of deportation, not only among undocumented immigrants, but also among their U.S. citizen children and networks of families and friends.[1] This pervasive fear leads to social isolation, health care avoidance, stress and anxiety, all of which have profound effects on physical and mental health.[2] Chronic stress contributes to increased cardiovascular disease, gastrointestinal problems, chronic pain, and decreased immune function.[3] ICE activities, such as workplace raids and detentions, have already increased fear among immigrants. The implementation of S-Comm statewide may exacerbate fear, stress, and anxiety in immigrants, and whole communities may suffer negative health consequences. Psychologists, teachers, and family members report that the children of these immigrants (the majority of whom are U.S. citizens) experience health, emotional, behavioral, and academic problems.[4]

The second major concern for public health is S-Comm’s impact on public safety in immigrant communities. The Everett study found that increased ICE presence caused immigrants to be more fearful of all people in authority, including police officers.  Mistrust between police and immigrant communities can lead to the underreporting of crime, leaving these communities vulnerable to violence and impairing officers’ ability to investigate and solve crimes.[5]  Formal police/ICE collaborations through S-Comm may lead to additional mistrust. While some say S-Comm helps fight crime by streamlining deportation of undocumented immigrants who have committed offenses, in reality many people being deported under S-Comm have never even been charged with a crime. In Boston, where the program began operating in 2008, more than half of those deported under S-Comm were classified “noncriminals.”[6]

A third major public health impact of S-Comm will be its effect on health care utilization. In the Everett study, the pervasive fear of apprehension by authorities and deportation led to decreased utilization of appropriate health care services. Immigrants reported being afraid to leave their homes to attend their medical appointments for fear of being stopped by police. In one instance, a man did not go to his clinic appointment because there were police cars in the street outside the clinic.  Decreased utilization limits patients’ ability to prevent disease onset; avoid costly, catastrophic health problems; manage chronic disease; and minimize the spread of contagious diseases that pose public health threats (tuberculosis, flu, etc). S-Comm poses serious risks to the health of individuals as well as the general public.

Although the effects of S-Comm will be felt most acutely by immigrants and their families, its health impact could extend far beyond individual immigrants and may pose consequences for the health of entire communities. Immigrant health and well-being are important to all. As health professionals concerned about the health of both our patients and our communities, we strongly advise our colleagues to remain vigilant and advocate for policies that will promote the optimal health and well-being of our patients and our communities.

Karen Hacker, MD MPH is Executive Director of the Institute for Community Health in Cambridge, MA. She is also an Associate Professor at Harvard Medical School. Her research interests include immigrant health, adolescent health, child mental health promotion and screening, and primary care.

Jennifer Kasper, MD, MPH is an attending pediatrician at Massachusetts General Hospital for Children, an Instructor at Harvard Medical School, and the Chair of the International Volunteer Committee for Doctors for Global Health. Her areas of expertise include health service delivery; rural community development; complex humanitarian emergencies; field-based operations research; health system strengthening; and curriculum development, training and mentorship of community health workers and other health professionals.

Juliana Morris, BA is a second-year student at Harvard Medical School pursuing a career in family medicine. Before entering medical school, she worked for three years with immigrant-serving non-profits in the U.S. and Mexico. Her research interests include immigrant health, access to care issues, and social determinants of health.

Related links:

The Institute for Community Health, Cambridge, MA: http://www.icommunityhealth.org/

US Immigration and Customs Enforcement – Secure Communities info page: http://www.ice.gov/secure_communities/

Uncover the Truth – Resources and info from the national movement to resist S-Comm: http://uncoverthetruth.org/

National Immigration Law Center – Spotlight on Local Law Enforcement Issues: http://www.nilc.org/immlawpolicy/locallaw/index.htm

[1] Hacker, K., J. Chu, C. Leung, R. Marra, A. Pirie, M. Brahimi, M. English, J. Beckmann, D. Acevedo-Garcia, and R.P. Marlin. In press. “The Impact of Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Immigrant Health: Perceptions of Immigrants in Everett, Massachusetts, USA.” Social Science & Medicine.

[2] For more on the link between fear of deportation and stress for both documented and undocumented immigrants see: C. Arbona, N. Olvera, N. Rodriguez, J. Haga, A. Linares, and M. Wiesner. 2010. “Acculturative Stress Among Documented and Undocumented Latino Immigrants in the United States.” Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences. 32(3): 362-384.

[3] D. Williams, S. Mohammed, J. Leavell, and C. Collins. 2010. “Race, socioeconomic status, and health: Complexities, ongoing challenges, and research opportunities.” Annals of the New York Academy of Science. 1186: 2009.

[5] T.R. Tyler and J. Fagan. 2008. “Legitimacy and Cooperation: Why Do People Help the Police Fight Crime in Their Communities?” Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law 6: 231-271.

[6] U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. 2010. Secure Communities. IDENT/IAFIS Interoperability.

Cite this:

Hacker, Karen, Jennifer Kasper, and Juliana Morris. 2011. S-Comm Immigration Initiative is Bad for Our Health. AccessDenied: A Conversation on Un/authorized Im/migration and Health. Accessed (date) at https://accessdeniedblog.wordpress.com/2011/07/21/s-comm-immigration-initiative-is-bad-for-our-health-karen-hacker-jennifer-kasper-and-juliana-morris/

  1. September 26, 2011 at 5:32 pm

    I am agreed with canoe84 “The comment by “reality checker,” is disappointing”

  2. August 25, 2011 at 8:44 am

    Lets look at the facts their is a reason that it hasnt been signed off and by there own admission the system is not accurate. Over half of the people flagged in the system are not even criminals its a joke. Human Rights anyone?

  3. canoe84
    July 26, 2011 at 2:08 am

    The comment by “reality checker,” is disappointing, and somehow manages to miss the fact that, of migrants affected by S Comm, the vast majority are NOT criminals (and nevermind the fact that criminals do emerge from their own communities, as Norway is painfully dealing with now).

    This is a great article. I am an MD, MPH from Michigan, and I have experience with migrants who tend to come to MI for seasonal work. I think we cannot emphasize enough that S-COMM and similar initiatives will FURTHER deter immigrants from using health care services, even for those with chronic health conditions that need to be addressed. Reality Checker also fails to recognize that migrants are DRIVEN to use emergency medical services precisely because they face limited access to primary health care.

    The US has so far overwhelmingly chosen to ignore human rights in its immigration policy. We need comprehensive care that will respect and protect the rights of migrants, including their right to health.

  4. Reality Checker
    July 22, 2011 at 3:09 pm

    Secure Communities has resulted in the removal of more than 77,000 migrants, including more than 28,000 convicted of aggravated felony offenses like murder, rape, and the sexual abuse of children.

    Yet you WANT these people in your neighborhood? Don’t you think rape and murder is bad for your health?

    Sad that you are supportive of criminals. Sad that you’re celebrating more crime and more costs to our emergency medical centers.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: